The Deficiency List Is the Last Real Say a Strata Gets
There is a point in every restoration project where the strata’s position changes from strong to weak, and it happens in a single transaction.
Before the holdback is released, the contractor has an unpaid balance and a commercial reason to return to the building. After it, correction depends on warranty terms and on goodwill.
Both of those are real and neither has the immediacy of money owed. Which makes everything that happens before that moment considerably more important than most councils appreciate at the time.
Holdback, and what it is actually for
In British Columbia, holdback is a portion of the contract value retained by the owner, governed by builders lien legislation. Its statutory purpose relates to protecting against lien claims by subtrades and suppliers.
In practice it also functions as the mechanism that gets deficiencies corrected, because it is the one thing available at exactly the point where the strata most needs one.
The legislative requirements around amount and timing apply regardless of what the contract says, and the contract sits alongside them. A strata should understand both before the project starts, and the property manager or the consultant is the right party to confirm the mechanics for that specific contract.
Inspect before the equipment comes down
This is the single most consequential piece of timing on the whole project, and it is routinely got wrong.
A minor deficiency identified while the swing stage is still hanging or the rope access rigging is still in place is a short correction. The same deficiency found two weeks later, after the access has been struck and the crew has moved to another building, requires full remobilization.
The correction then costs many times the value of the item. The contractor will resist, and their objection is not unreasonable. Everybody ends up arguing about something that could have been fixed in half an hour.
On a phased project, that means inspecting at the end of each phase while the access for that elevation is in place, rather than compiling one list at the end of the job. It should be written into the programme described in the post on phasing restoration around occupied buildings as a defined hold point.
What belongs on the list
Four categories:
Work not meeting the specification. The specified product was not used, the specified thickness was not achieved, the detail was not built as drawn.
Incomplete work. Something in the scope that was not done.
Damage caused during construction. Landscaping, finishes, resident property, adjacent surfaces.
Anything not functioning as intended. A drain that does not drain, a vent that does not vent, a door that no longer closes.
What does not belong is anything outside the contract scope. Items the strata would like done, improvements suggested during the work, and conditions that existed before the project all fall outside it.
Including them weakens the list. Once a contractor sees out-of-scope items on a deficiency list, every item on it becomes negotiable, and the genuine deficiencies get argued alongside the wishes. Keeping the list strictly to contract non-compliance is what makes it enforceable.
Who writes it
The consultant, from their own inspection, incorporating items raised by the strata and by residents.
All three inputs are needed. A list built only from resident complaints misses technical deficiencies that occupants have no way to identify. A list prepared without resident input misses things only the people living there see: a balcony that now holds water, a window that no longer opens, a stain that appeared after the work.
Residents should be given a defined window and a specific way to report items, ideally with a form and a deadline, as part of the communication approach set out in the post on resident communication during envelope restoration. An open-ended invitation produces items arriving for months, long after the list has been agreed.
Disputes are decided by the documents
When a contractor disagrees that something is a deficiency, the resolution comes from the contract documents.
A disagreement about whether work meets a clearly written requirement is short, because the requirement can be read and the work can be measured against it.
A disagreement about whether work meets an unwritten expectation is long, because there is nothing to measure against and both parties are describing what they believed was intended.
This is why the specification quality determines how the deficiency stage goes, months before anyone reaches it. A tender package that defines products, thicknesses, preparation standards, and testing requirements produces a short deficiency stage. One that describes the work in general terms produces an argument. The elements that matter are set out in the post on envelope tender scope of work.
Do not defer to the warranty
The tempting resolution for a contested item is to accept it on the basis that the warranty will cover it if it becomes a problem.
That is generally a mistake. A warranty covers defined failures within defined terms. It was not written to complete work that was not finished to specification, and a claim against it for that purpose is likely to be declined, for the reasons set out in the post on building envelope warranty claims.
The moment to require the work to meet the contract is while the contract is still open.
Distinguishing a deficiency from a warranty item
These two get conflated during the closing weeks of a project, and the distinction matters because they are resolved differently.
A deficiency is work that does not comply with the contract, identified before acceptance. It is corrected under the contract, at the contractor’s cost, before final payment.
A warranty item is a failure occurring after acceptance, within the warranty period, in work that complied with the contract when it was accepted. It is resolved under the warranty terms.
The practical difference is who bears the cost and how quickly it gets attention. Deficiencies are corrected because payment depends on it. Warranty items depend on the terms being met and the claim being accepted, which is the process described in the post on building envelope warranty claims.
Anything visible before acceptance should be on the deficiency list rather than left to become a warranty question later.
Resident items and how to handle them
Residents will report items during the closing phase, and they will be a mixture of genuine deficiencies, pre-existing conditions, and requests.
Sorting them takes judgement and it should be done by the consultant rather than by the council, because a council sorting resident complaints against a construction contract is being asked to make technical decisions it is not equipped for and will be blamed for either way.
The three categories are worth naming explicitly when the responses go back out. Something the contractor caused and will correct. Something that existed before the project and is outside the scope. Something the resident would like that was never in the contract.
Owners generally accept all three answers when they are given clearly and promptly. What generates conflict is silence, or an item being accepted informally on site by someone with no authority and then not happening.
That is a good argument for a single reporting channel and a written response to every item, however brief.
Set a period, and an end to it
The deficiency period needs a defined duration in the contract, with consequences for exceeding it.
Without one it drifts. Items get partially addressed, correspondence slows, and the crew that did the work disperses to other projects and becomes progressively harder to reassemble. Six months later the strata is chasing a company that has no one available who remembers the building.
A defined period, a defined list, and a release tied to acceptance rather than to a date is a structure that resolves. It is also entirely normal in construction contracts, and a contractor who objects to it strongly is telling the strata something worth listening to.
Sources and further reading
- Government of British Columbia, Builders Lien Act, holdback provisions, referenced 2026
- Condominium Home Owners Association of BC, guidance on major repair contracts and completion, referenced 2026
- Canadian Construction Documents Committee, standard construction contract forms, substantial performance and deficiency provisions, referenced 2026
- Allweathercoating project records, Metro Vancouver, 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
More from BC Strata Building Envelope Guide
The Records From This Project Are for the Council in 2041
Every restoration produces knowledge about the building. Most of it leaves with the crew, and the next council pays to rediscover it.
Read article →Glass Guardrails Need Maintenance Nobody Scheduled
Structural glass balustrades became standard on Metro Vancouver towers. The glass is the visible part, and the parts that need inspecting are the fittings holding it.
Read article →Choosing the Consultant Is the Decision That Sets Everything Else
The envelope consultant writes the scope, evaluates the bids, and decides what counts as complete. A strata gets one chance to pick well, before anything else is decided.
Read article →