Resealing Windows Buys Time. It Does Not Fix a Failed Window
Two towers, both around thirty years old, both in Metro Vancouver, both reporting water at the windows on upper floors during southeasterly storms.
One of them has a maintenance problem that a caulking programme will resolve. The other needs its windows replaced. The symptom in the suites is identical, and the cost difference between the two answers is enormous.
Getting this diagnosis right is the highest-value piece of work a council can commission before spending anything.
Two entirely different failures
The perimeter seal is the joint between the window frame and the surrounding wall, on the exterior. It is a sealant joint with a finite service life, and its deterioration is expected. Resealing it is maintenance in the same category as repainting: it will need doing again, and the timing depends on exposure and on the product used.
The window unit is everything inside the frame: the glazing seals, the frame corners and joints, the thermal break, the hardware, and the drainage designed into the assembly. When any of those fail, the water is crossing inside the window itself.
The distinction matters because exterior sealant cannot fix an interior failure. A perfectly executed resealing programme on a building whose windows have failed internally will stop nothing, and the strata will have spent a substantial sum to confirm a diagnosis it could have established beforehand.
Signs the unit itself has failed
Fogging or condensation between the panes of a sealed unit is definitive. It means the seal around the insulating glass has failed and the cavity is no longer sealed. That is a unit replacement, and no exterior work addresses it.
Water appearing at the bottom corners of the frame, on the interior, points to water inside the frame that is not draining. Deteriorated or separated frame joints, visible at the corners, indicate the frame itself is no longer continuous.
Hardware that no longer pulls the sash tight against its seal produces both drafts and water entry on operable windows, and it is often mistaken for a sealant problem because the symptom appears at an edge.
Drafts with the window fully closed, and a persistent cold surface on the interior frame in winter, suggest a thermal break failure. That relates directly to the condensation issues described in the guide on window condensation, because a cold frame produces surface condensation that owners frequently report as a leak.
The mistake that creates leaks
Most windows are designed to admit some water and get rid of it.
Water that gets past the outer glazing seal is expected to collect in a channel within the frame and drain out through small openings at the sill. This is the same principle as the drainage described in the post on blocked weep holes in rainscreen cavities, applied at the scale of a single window.
Exterior resealing work sometimes covers those openings. A technician running a continuous bead along the sill, doing what looks like thorough work, closes the drainage path.
The consequence is immediate and counterintuitive: a window that was managing water perfectly well starts leaking into the suite, days or weeks after the strata paid for work intended to stop leaks. It is one of the more common causes of a resealing programme appearing to make a building worse.
Any resealing specification should state explicitly that frame drainage openings remain clear, and it should be verified at handover.
Establishing where water actually enters
The tool for this is water testing, applied systematically rather than by hosing the wall and watching.
Controlled testing isolates one component at a time: the perimeter joint alone, then the glazing seal, then the frame, wetting each in sequence while someone watches from inside. That sequence identifies which element admits water, which is exactly the question the repair decision turns on. The method is set out in the post on field water testing to ASTM E1105.
Testing a representative sample across different elevations matters, because exposure varies substantially around a building. In this region the south and west elevations weather faster than the north, and it is entirely normal for one elevation to need replacement while another has years of life remaining.
That variation is also what makes partial replacement a legitimate option rather than a compromise.
Weighing the two paths
Resealing is far less disruptive. It is exterior work, accessed by rope or swing stage, and residents are largely unaffected beyond notice of technicians outside their windows. It can be phased by elevation and paused for weather. It has a defined and repeating cost.
Replacement is a different kind of project. It requires interior access to every suite, work inside people’s homes, and a period during which the suite is open to the weather. Furniture moves, window coverings come down, and scheduling has to accommodate residents who work from home, work nights, or cannot easily vacate.
Councils reliably underestimate that second half. The construction is straightforward for a competent installer; the coordination is where these projects go wrong, and it deserves the planning described in the post on resident communication during envelope restoration.
Against that, replacement resolves the problem for decades and improves thermal performance, condensation behaviour, and noise. Resealing addresses one component and leaves the rest of the assembly at whatever age it already was.
Partial replacement is a legitimate answer
The decision does not have to be all or nothing, and on many buildings the honest answer is a mix.
Exposure varies substantially around a building in this region. A southwest elevation taking wind-driven rain off the Strait weathers faster than a sheltered northeast face on the same tower, and it is normal to find one elevation with failed units and another with a decade of life remaining.
Replacing the failed elevations and resealing the sound ones spends the money where it does work. It also spreads the capital cost, which for a strata funding through a special levy or a reserve draw is not a minor consideration.
The cost is complexity. The building then has two window systems of different ages, with different details, different warranties, and a visible difference from outside if the products do not match closely. Future maintenance has to track which elevation is which.
That trade is worth making deliberately, with the appearance consequence stated to owners before the vote rather than discovered afterward.
What happens to the interface
Whichever path is chosen, the junction between the window and the wall is where the water was getting in, and it is the detail that determines whether the new work performs.
On a replacement, the opening is exposed and the interface can be rebuilt properly: the weather barrier lapped to the frame, a sill flashing with end dams installed, and drainage provided at the sill. That is the opportunity replacement offers beyond the window itself, and it is frequently the larger part of the benefit.
On a resealing programme, the interface is not opened. The work addresses the outer sealant joint and leaves whatever is behind it as found. That is appropriate where the underlying detail is sound and it is a limitation worth understanding, because a resealing programme cannot fix a missing sill flashing.
Where investigation shows the interface detail is the problem rather than either the sealant or the window, that finding changes the scope again. It is another reason the assessment described above has to precede the decision rather than follow it.
Making the decision defensible
For a whole-building decision, the assessment should be documented by someone independent of whoever will do the work.
That documentation needs to state where water was observed entering, on which elevations, under what test conditions, and what proportion of units show unit-level failure rather than perimeter failure. With that in hand, a council can defend either decision to its owners, and can put a properly scoped tender to market rather than comparing quotes for different scopes.
Without it, the strata is choosing between a caulking contractor who recommends caulking and a window supplier who recommends windows, which is not a decision so much as a coin toss with a sales pitch attached.
The buildings that get this wrong are usually not the ones that chose incorrectly. They are the ones that chose without finding out.
Sources and further reading
- ASTM International, ASTM E1105 Standard Test Method for Field Determination of Water Penetration of Installed Exterior Windows, referenced 2026
- BC Housing, Building Enclosure Design Guide, window installation and interface detailing, referenced 2026
- Canadian Standards Association, CSA A440 Windows, performance requirements, referenced 2026
- Allweathercoating window and sealant assessment records, Metro Vancouver, 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
More from Sealant & Caulking Guide
Every Vent, Pipe, and Conduit Is a Hole Somebody Made Later
A wall is designed as a continuous system and then trades cut through it for decades. Each penetration is a detail, and most of them were never detailed at all.
Read article →A Sealant Joint Fails Because of Its Shape, Not Its Brand
Two buildings using the same premium sealant get different results. The one that lasts had the right joint width, the right depth, and a backer rod doing its job.
Read article →Storefront Glazing: Why Ground-Floor Retail Leaks Differently
A storefront takes splash from the sidewalk, door slams all day, and pressure washing at street level. Its sealant fails faster than anything higher up the building.
Read article →