A Sealer and a Coating Are Not Two Grades of the Same Thing
A strata receives two prices for protecting a parkade slab. One is considerably lower and is described as a sealer application.
The council reasonably reads this as a budget option for the same outcome. It is not. The two products address different problems, and using one where the other is required is not a saving.
Two different mechanisms
A penetrating sealer is absorbed into the concrete and reacts within the pore structure. Silanes, siloxanes, and crystalline products all work this way, reducing the concrete’s capacity to absorb water and the chlorides dissolved in it.
Nothing sits on the surface. The concrete looks essentially as it did before, which is why sealers are used where appearance must not change, and it is also why their performance is difficult to assess by looking.
A traffic coating builds a continuous film on top of the concrete. It carries vehicle traffic, presents a physical barrier to water and chlorides, provides a wearing surface, and in elastomeric formulations bridges hairline cracks in the substrate.
It is visible, its thickness is measurable, and its condition can be assessed by inspection.
The crack is the deciding factor
This is the difference that determines which product a slab needs.
A sealer reduces absorption through sound concrete. It does nothing about a crack, because a crack is a gap rather than a porous surface, and water passes straight through it.
Concrete slabs crack. Shrinkage cracking, thermal cracking, and flexural cracking over supports are all normal, and the crack repair options are set out in the guide on parkade crack repair.
So on a suspended slab over parked cars, storage, or occupied space, where water coming through the slab is a problem, the protection has to handle cracks. That is a coating or a membrane.
On a slab on grade, where the objective is reducing chloride absorption into the concrete rather than preventing water passage to a space below, a sealer has a legitimate role and is the appropriate specification in many cases.
Chlorides are the underlying threat
On a Metro Vancouver parkade, the deterioration mechanism that matters is chloride ingress from road salt carried in on vehicles through the winter.
Chlorides penetrate the concrete, reach the reinforcing steel, and initiate the corrosion described in the post on rebar corrosion and concrete delamination. The corrosion products expand and crack the concrete from within, and the repair at that stage is structural rather than protective.
Both product types reduce chloride ingress. A coating does it by excluding water from the surface entirely. A sealer does it by reducing the concrete’s absorption. The coating is the more complete barrier and the sealer is less intrusive and less expensive.
Where a slab already has significant chloride contamination, neither product removes it, and the protection question becomes secondary to the assessment described in the post on cathodic protection for concrete parkades.
Failure modes differ, and one is invisible
A coating fails visibly. It wears through in the wheel paths, loses its texture, cracks, and debonds at the edges of worn areas. An inspection finds it, and the timing of a recoat can be planned against observed condition, using the approach in the post on parkade membrane recoat schedules.
A sealer fails invisibly. Its effectiveness declines with wear and weathering, and nothing about the surface appearance changes. There is no visual cue at all, which means a sealed slab that was treated twelve years ago looks exactly like one treated last year.
That has a practical consequence: sealer reapplication gets forgotten. A building with a coating knows when it needs attention because it can see it. A building with a sealer needs a record and a schedule, and the record is usually the thing that goes missing between property managers.
Water drop testing gives a rough indication of whether a surface is still repelling water, and it is a reasonable periodic check on a sealed slab.
Compatibility, before anything is specified
If a slab was sealed years ago and someone now proposes a coating, that is a compatibility question requiring an answer before the product is selected.
Residual sealer in the pore structure can interfere with the adhesion of a coating applied over it. The coating goes down, looks correct, and debonds within a few years in a pattern that gets attributed to the product or the applicator.
Establishing what is on a slab means checking records first and testing where records do not exist. Adhesion testing on a trial area is inexpensive relative to recoating a whole parkade and finding out afterward.
The same caution applies to curing compounds on newer concrete, which are frequently still present and are a common cause of the adhesion failures described in the post on coating adhesion failure and blistering.
Application conditions differ between the two
The two product types make different demands on the applicator and on the schedule, and this affects what a parkade closure looks like.
A sealer is absorbed rather than built up. Application is comparatively quick, the surface can usually take traffic sooner, and there is no film thickness to verify. What matters is that the concrete is clean and dry enough to absorb the product, and that the coverage rate matches what the manufacturer specifies, because an under-applied sealer looks identical to a correctly applied one.
A coating is a built system with a specified thickness, applied in defined coats with cure time between them. The surface preparation is more demanding, usually involving mechanical profiling to give the coating something to key into. Substrate moisture has to be within limits, for the reasons set out in the post on substrate moisture testing before coating, and the cure schedule determines how long the area is out of service.
On an occupied building that difference drives the resident impact. A parkade level closed for two days is a different conversation with owners than one closed for a week, and it belongs in the comparison alongside the technical merits.
Verifying that you got what you paid for
This is where the two diverge most sharply, and it is worth knowing before signing a contract.
A coating can be verified. Wet film thickness is checked during application, dry film thickness can be measured afterward, adhesion can be tested on a sample area, and holidays or thin spots can be found. A consultant reviewing a coating installation has objective measures available.
A sealer largely cannot be verified by inspection. Once absorbed, there is nothing to measure. The practical checks are documenting the quantity of product used against the area covered, which establishes whether the specified coverage rate was achieved, and water drop testing after cure to confirm the surface repels water.
That means a sealer contract should specify the product, the coverage rate, and a requirement to record quantities used per area. Without those, the strata is relying entirely on the applicator, with no way to establish afterward whether the specification was met.
Deciding for a specific building
The questions that determine the answer are not about price.
Is the slab suspended over something that water reaching would damage? What condition is the concrete in, and has chloride testing been done? What exposure does the area see, particularly on the ramp and near the entrance, where the loading is highest for the reasons set out in the post on parkade ramp coatings? What is already on the surface?
With those answered, the specification follows, and the two prices the council received are revealed as prices for two different scopes rather than two bids for the same one.
Sources and further reading
- Canadian Standards Association, CSA S413 Parking Structures, protection system requirements, referenced 2026
- American Concrete Institute, ACI 362.1R Guide for the Design and Construction of Durable Concrete Parking Structures, referenced 2026
- ASTM International, ASTM C1583 Standard Test Method for Tensile Strength of Concrete Surfaces, referenced 2026
- Allweathercoating parkade assessment records, Metro Vancouver, 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
More from Parkade Waterproofing Guide
Parkade Ramps Wear Out Faster Than the Rest of the Deck
The ramp takes every vehicle in the building, turning wheels, braking loads, and all the road salt carried in during winter. It needs a different specification from the flat parking areas.
Read article →Podium Decks and Planters: The Leaks That Show Up in the Parkade Below
A landscaped podium deck sits directly over occupied space. When its waterproofing fails, the water appears in the parkade ceiling, and the soil, drainage layer, and planting all have to come off to fix it.
Read article →Expansion Joint Systems on Vancouver Parkade and Plaza Decks
A leak staining the cars in a Vancouver parkade often starts at a deck expansion joint above. How compression seals, strip seals, and membrane joints work — and fail.
Read article →